The Best Eyebrow Pencil Shades for Gray Hair: A Comprehensive Guide

The Best Eyebrow Pencil Shades for Gray Hair: A Comprehensive Guide

Going gray leaves many people concerned that their age is starting to show. What most don’t realize is that age is just one of the many factors that cause the shift in color. Finding gray hair on your scalp or brows can also be due to genetics, current stress levels, unhealthy habits such as smoking, or even an unbalanced diet. Half the time, this can be reversed by making lifestyle changes. But ask yourself - do you really want to hide it?

Silver locks can offer anyone a more distinguished look and oftentimes, we find ourselves embracing this new phase in life eventually. So, whether you are looking to cover up some gray, fill in a few bald spots, or discover ways to enhance it, we’ve found some great eyebrow pencils for you.

In this article, we talk about what color eyebrow pencil for gray hair works best and our most recommended alternative that will save you time and effort.

How to Determine the Right Eyebrow Color for Gray Hair?

How to Determine the Right Eyebrow Color for Gray Hair?
Image by Freepik

Before our hair turned gray, we more or less had a guide on what hue to stick to and just played with lighter or darker shades. Now that we’re growing into our silver years, does that rule still apply? Wouldn’t a natural hair shade look too dark against the gray, or wouldn’t apply the same gray make one’s face look washed out? We’re here to provide some answers.

Factors To Consider: Skin Tone and Natural Hair Color

Oftentimes, head hair can lighten faster than brow hair and experts suggest this is one way to stay youthful. Keeping your brows your natural color even when your locks turn gray on your head can help keep your face properly framed. Perhaps the only difference would be to apply a much lighter and gentler layer than you would in the past.

However, if you’d prefer consistency and to turn your brows gray, opt for a shade that is one to two times darker to create depth or one to two shades lighter for a softer look.

For those with little to no brow hair, consider your skin’s undertone when looking for a complementary hue. Those with a more golden complexion would benefit best from a warmer brow shade, and those with a somewhat pale or cooler skin tone should go for bolder colors.

Shades of Gray: Which One Suits You Best?

Go for a shade of gray that compliments your skin tone and your existing head of hair. For example, a shade of gray with a touch of blue is perfect for cooler undertones while gray brow pencils with a hint of orange can work wonders for sun-kissed skin. You would also want to choose a shade that is subtly darker than your current head of hair.

Using A Spoolie Brush For A Natural Look

No matter the hue or shade you go far, a spoolie brush will be your brow’s best friend. After applying the product, always brush it in to blend with your skin and brow hair. This small step does wonders and creates a natural finish you’d absolutely love.

What Are the Best Eyebrow Pencils For Gray Hair?

Best Eyebrow Pencils For Gray Hair

More and more makeup brands are strengthening their women's (and men's) empowerment campaigns by offering a wider range of products that allow individuals to love their natural selves. This includes embracing going gray and rocking that silver lining (literally). Below are a few of the top recommendations we found on the market that just may be the solution for you:

Top Recommendations For Gray Eyebrow Pencils

Based on reviews online, some of the best eyebrow pencils for gray hair include:

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in Granite

Nikol Skinny Brow Pencil in Soft Gray

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil in Cool Grey

Jones Road The Brow Pencil in Gray by Bobbi Brown

Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Fiber Eyebrow Pencil in Cool Grey

How To Choose The Best Brow Color For Gray Hair

Keep in mind that just because you have gray here doesn’t mean you can only get gray brow pencils. Some similar colors may for a perfect blend as well so long as you get them in a complimentary hue.

For those who prefer darker brows, we recommend considering brown, black-brown, or dark gray shades. For those who want to keep their brows light, perhaps a lighter brown, darker blonde, or light gray should do the trick.

Best Eyebrow Makeup Tips For Silver Hair

With silver hair comes a bit more responsibility but a whole lot of fun. If you are new to the era, here are the best tips we have to make it your best phase yet:

#1 Go Gently

Now, this should be a rule even in our younger years and pre-gray brows but if you haven’t started yet, it’s definitely time now. Choose brow makeup products that are gentle on your skin and made of safe, eco-friendly ingredients. This ensures your system has the right kind of nourishment and support.

#2 Not Too Shady

Remember to stick to only one or two shades lighter or darker. Anything more contrasting on either side of the spectrum can look unnatural.

#3 Skin Is In

While we used to rely on our natural hair color to base our brow hue on, those with silver hair should rely more on their skin undertone to find the perfect shade. Warm for warm, cool for cool, and have fun along the way to finding the sweet spot.

What Are The Best Techniques For Applying Eyebrow Pencils?

What Are The Best Techniques For Applying Eyebrow Pencils?
Image by Getty

The thought of makeup products may seem daunting to some but luckily, brow pencils are as straightforward as they appear to be. This tool can greatly help those with thinning brows due to medical reasons, age, over-plucking, and other common causes.

Step-By-Step Guide To Shaping Your Eyebrows

Step 1: Define Your Shape

To color inside the lines (literally) and get your ideal shape, it’s best to start with an outline of your brows. If you want to learn more about brow shapes for your facial features and how to outline your arch, check out our article on Eyebrow Shapes.

Step 2: Apply Swift Strokes

Once you have your outline, apply swift and light strokes that mimic hair strands.

Step 3: Blend, Blend, Blend

Whether you are going for bold and defined or soft and powdery, it’s a must to blend in your brow product for a natural finish. Especially if you experience brow hair falling out, blending it in can close the gaps.

Tips For Blending With A Spoolie Brush

When it comes to handling a spoolie brush, we recommend an upward and outward motion to gently lift your brow strands in place and blend the product in.

What Can Be Considered Over Eyebrow Pencils For Gray Hair?

Brow pencils, though being the beginner-friendly of the lot, can still be quite a challenge especially when our grips are not as steady. For an instant way to get perfectly shaped, natural-looking gray brows in under a minute, we recommend an Eyebrow Stamp Kit.

Eyebrow Stamp Kit

This product is not only great for sparse brows, but it works wonders for those with zero brow hair as well.

Why Is It Better To Use A Brow Stamp?

When it comes to applying makeup, there’s going to be a learning curve regardless of the product you choose. With a brow stamp, it’s an instant success even on your first try. This not only saves you time in practicing and applying it every morning, but it can also ease your worries about getting your brow to look as natural as possible.

Each kit comes with 25 stencils, each with varying arch height, length, and size, ensuring you get the perfect brow shape for your facial features and more. You can also choose from 11 different hues and get a FREE extra hue when you avail of our special offer.

Once you have your chosen stencil and stamp color, all you have to do is dab in it and blend it out with a spoolie, which is also included in the kit. It takes seconds but stays on for hours!

You’re All Set

We hope this quick guide sheds some light on how you can choose what color eyebrow pencil for gray hair and the top alternative from My Two Brows that can save you more time and effort in the long run. Now, get out there and live your best Silver Fox year yet!

Back to blog